The Best Minds

The Best Minds: A Story of Friendship, Madness, and the Tragedy of Good Intentions by Jonathan Rosen  562 pp.

In 1973 the Rosen family moved into a house in New Rochelle, NY, across the street from the Laudor family. Young Jonathan Rosen and Michael Laudor soon were best friends and inseparable through high school and into college. Both young men were highly intelligent and ambitious. Michael completed college in three years as Summa Cum Laude. He soon went to work for a high power consulting firm. Before long Michael is hospitalized after a psychotic break and is diagnosed with schizophrenia. Johnathan does his best to be supportive while living in California earning Masters and Doctorate degrees. Michael spends time in a halfway house before using his deferred acceptance to Yale Law School. The administration and faculty are very supportive and accommodate Michael's difficulties which includes daily hallucinations of his room engulfed in flames and his parents being Nazi imposters. In spite of that he received his law degree. Soon he was in talks with Ron Howard's production company about making a film of Laudor's life. However, mental illness is unpredictable and things soon went sideways. Michael and his fiancée, Caroline Costello, shared an apartment until the day in 1998 when he brutally stabs her to death. He was captured that night after assaulting police officers It took six weeks before he realized she was dead after not understanding why she hadn't come to see him. Because of the vagaries of the legal system in such cases it took awhile before Michael was incarcerated in an institution in New York. He remains there and his illness is reevaluated for the possibility of release every two years . Much of this book is an examination of the treatment of the mentally ill by both the medical and professions. Because mental illness is so unpredictable it is impossible to find a black & white solution. In spite of his closeness to Laudor and his family, Rosen presents a balanced, informative, and compassionate story of a tragic situation.

Ron Howard never produced a film about Michael Laudor but made "A Beautiful Mind" about schizophrenic mathematician, John Nash a few years after the murder of Costello.

The Benevolent Society of Ill-Mannered Ladies

The Benevolent Society of Ill-Mannered Ladies by Alison Goodman (2023) 448 pages

It's 1812 and Lady Augusta and her twin sister Lady Julia, aged 42, are working behind the scenes to right some wrongs. Their parents are dead and their younger brother, who is now head of the family, tries to hold the reins over them since they are both unmarried. Augusta and Julia are different in temperament. Augusta is not afraid to speak up, while Julia is more the peacemaker. They work well together, along with their butler Weatherly, and eventually with a former Lord who is on the run because he was found guilty of killing another man in a duel and is supposed to be serving out a prison term in Australia. Over the course of the book, the women, along with their allies, work to save a number of women and children from mistreatment, as secretly as possible. 

The book's setting in the 1800s belies its modern feeling, and the strong wishes that the women have to help those in great need. There is some talk about whether God exists, women's rights (or rather, the lack of them), and more. The book ends after their third adventure, but before all the details can be worked out. However, I hear that a sequel is in the works.