We are competitive library employees who are using this blog for our reading contest against each other and Missouri libraries up to the challenge.
Pages
▼
Friday, May 31, 2013
The Golem and the Jinni / Helene Wecker 486 pp.
I really wanted to like this book. It's the story of Chava, a freshly-made Golem who finds herself all alone on the streets of late 19th century New York until she meets Ahmad, a centuries-old Jinni in much the same circumstances. And Wecker wrote a terrific beginning, setting the stage for a story that promised suspense, romance and fairy tale magic. The end was not bad either, wrapping things up in a satisfying if unsurprising way. But the middle! It went on for far too long so that finishing the book became a chore. More disappointing was the inability to warm to either of the main characters. Yes, Chava is meant to be a destructive automaton made of clay, and she transcended that, but not by enough. And Ahmad is peevish and 2-dimensional. (A good trick, since his essence is fire.) Wecker also seems to have backed away from the promise of the title: shouldn't such a book have something to say about the intermingling of the two cultures represented by all the Golems and the Jinnis of the world? I couldn't find any strong contemporary resonance here, only hints of a better book that never materialized.

No comments:
Post a Comment